Friday, July 18, 2025

Both/And: A Sermon for the 6th Sunday After Pentecost


May only truth be spoken, and truth received. Amen.

Interesting things always seem to happen when Mary and Martha are involved. It was Mary and Martha’s brother Lazarus that Jesus called out of the tomb and into new life. And it was at a dinner at their house just before Passover that Mary anointed Jesus’ feet with a pound of costly perfume. Makes me wonder if Jesus routinely heads back to visit these friends because he felt most comfortable there, and they provided a change of pace to the stress and hard work that occupied most of Jesus’ time. In any case, here we are, once again, at Mary and Martha’s house in Bethany, just outside of Jerusalem.

 

They say that the biggest motivator to clean one’s house is to have a guest arrive on their doorstep. How about if you have 70 guests show up? The disciples had just returned from their travels, weary and probably hungry. Jesus probably thought, “hey my friends Mary and Martha live around here. I bet they won’t mind if we drop in!” As you could imagine, Martha went on a tear around the house – cleaning, getting started on cooking food, putting out drinks, filling bowls of water for people to wash their feet – all of the things a good host would do. Is it any wonder that Martha felt a little annoyed when she looked in on the company and found her darling sister Mary just sitting there, listening to Jesus teach. What would you do if it were you? How would you feel?

 

Martha put up a stink and complains to Jesus, trying to get him to convince Mary to help her with the chores and the tasks. I suppose she has grounds for such a complaint because, in that time, women were supposed to be servers not learners. So, by sitting at Jesus’ feet instead of running around taking care of their guests, Mary was going against acceptable customs. Martha’s expectation that Jesus would chastise Mary for going against the rules makes sense. Instead, Jesus takes Martha to task, telling her, “You are worried and distracted by many things, but few things are needed – indeed only one. Mary has chosen the better part, which will not be taken away from her.”

 

The competition between Mary and Martha has always been the typical understanding of this story. Mary, the ever-loving disciple who sits obediently at Jesus’ feet and is often described as the ultimate goal for all Christians. Martha, the always-busy never-just-sitting-and-listening host who cries to Jesus about how she has to do all the work while Mary just sits there at Jesus’ feet. The common lesson being a plea for us to be less like Martha and more like Mary. But this is an awful lesson, one that pits two sisters against each other, that pits women against each other, and pits each of us against the other as we fight to win some sort of “I’m a better Christian than you” competition.

 

There is no reason for this to be an either/or situation. There are times for listening and there are times for action, with no need for debate on the priority of contemplative listener and the dutiful activist. It’s not about choosing to be one or the other, but about doing what is needed in the moment, being in the moment, and focusing on God in the midst of duty and routine. As Rachel Held Evans states, “If we censure Martha too harshly, she may abandon serving altogether, and if we commend Mary too profusely, she may sit there forever.  There is a time to go and do; there is a time to listen and reflect.  Knowing which and when is a matter of spiritual discernment.” Jesus is not chastising Martha for her hospitality for hospitality is very important to Jesus. The work that Martha is doing is necessary and important, but it seems that she has put being the perfect host above hearing the word of God. And that is the warning Jesus is giving to Martha in this moment. It’s also a warning to us that if we make ourselves too busy, we might miss out on hearing God’s message.

 

What Martha needed was to just stop. Sit down. Listen. Sometimes, whatever we are doing, even if we’re trying to do good, God really needs us to stop. Stop doing so much, stop trying so hard. Stop trying to fix everything. Stop trying to justify yourself by looking busy. Stop doing and start listening. Sit down at Jesus’ feet and try to hear where God’s Spirit is moving in your life and in the world around you. The world we live in is full of problems, problems we all want to fix. But sometimes we want to fix problems more than we want to understand them. The problems we are facing today don’t have easy fixes: how best to protect the environment? How to distribute resources fairly? How to protect ourselves while staying open and welcoming? All of these issues require careful, prayerful discernment. At least, they do if we are going to respond from a place of love and not fear. Jesus’ call is to come more and more into the way of love. But finding love amid the fear that surrounds us takes some work on our part. We have to seek out God’s presence. We have to set aside the noise and distractions of the world before we can best hear God’s voice. Today, we need to sit and listen. Tomorrow, we can act.

 

Mary chose to sit still at the feet of her teacher, Jesus. Martha was asked to stop and join them. And we too are called to stop, to put aside our many tasks and all that distracts us, and to sit at Jesus’ feet. We can pray to God, read the Scriptures regularly, be present to God and God’s presence in Christ to us, and listen for the still small voice of the Holy Spirit in our hearts. It is there and God is always reaching out to us in love. During St. Joan of Arc’s trial, she was questioned as to whether the voice of God she claimed to hear wasn’t merely a voice in her head. She responded by saying essentially, “How else do you think God speaks to us?”

 

Amen.





Resources:
pulpitfiction.com
episcopalchurch.org
"Feasting on the Word" edited by David L Bartlett and Barbara Taylor Brown

No comments:

Post a Comment